I suppose everyone has a black sheep or two in their family tree, but through online newspapers, I discovered I have two great-great-grandfathers who were murderers! I wrote about the first one, my maternal great-great-grandfather, Daniel Batson, in part one:
My Black Sheep Ancestors
Daniel Batson killed his son-in-law because he continually beat his wife, Dan's daughter, and he never served prison time, although he was jailed locally for a couple of years. Killing the bad guy sort of makes him a bit of a hero, not a man of whom to be completely ashamed. However, my paternal great-great grandfather, John Feland Button, is an entirely different story. It was a shock to find his story revealed in online newspapers. Unlike Dan Batson whose actions lived through family stories in my mother's family, John F. Button's were a dark secret family members took to their graves. Even now, there are family members still living who are a bit too close to the people involved, so I have not shared this information with them. However, I think it's important information to share. I and my mother before me have researched the Button family for decades, and there is so much that is unknown about this family. One thing that was never answered among all the Button cousins and Button research I found available--what happened to John Feland Button and his wife? Because so many want to know that answer, I decided to post what I learned on this blog to be found by those who diligently search for the answer. It's not a story I'm proud to broadcast freely.
John Feland Button
John Feland Button was my great-great-grandfather on my father's side. His daughter, Clara, was my great-grandmother, and I knew her until I was eight years old when she died shortly before her eighty-sixth birthday. Her son, Emanuel Tillman Warner, was my grandfather, father to my Daddy, Francis Eugene Warner.
John Feland Button was the son of Harmon M. Button and Sarah Adaline Cain. He was born 15 May 1845, in Mississippi, probably Wilkinson Co. His siblings were James J. Button (1839-1862, died in the Civil War), Benjamin A. Button (1842-?), and Frances F. Button Brannon (1850-1890). He married Mary Elizabeth Huff (1852-1896), daughter of Holloway Huff and Caroline Pomeroy, 26 November 1874, in Wilkinson Co., Mississippi. They had the following children: Francis Jones Button (1875-1951), Caroline Elizabeth "Bessie" Button Foster (1877-1923), Clara Adaline Button Warner (1880-1966), John Feland Button Jr. (1882-1971), Byron Pomeroy Button (1884-1896), George Allen Button (1886-?), Catherine Theresa "Katie" Button Hughes (1889-1930), Mamie Huff Button (1891-?), Nellie Verna Button Justice Case (1893-1969), and Claude Howard Button (1896-1978). The 1896 death date routinely found online for John Feland Button Sr. is just one person's guess that has been copied over and over by other researchers. It's based on a rumor that he and his wife and son Byron died in some epidemic. There's another rumor that his wife died in childbirth in 1896 with her last child, Howard. I believe that one to be true; she died in childbirth or soon thereafter, as evidenced by the information I found in the newspapers. As for John Feland Button Sr., he died 20 May 1899, in a prison in West Feliciana Parish, Louisiana. The morbid story is revealed in the following newspaper articles:
Article in a January 22, 1898, St. Landry, Louisiana, newspaper.
The date and the age of the young mother makes her my great-grandmother, Clara Adaline Button. Her 21-year-old sister, Bessie, was married and living with her husband by this time. The younger Miss Button mentioned in the article would have been Katie, not quite nine at the time. Mamie and Nellie would have been six and four, resp. It is obvious that Clara's mother was not alive at this time. It seems logical to me that Mr. Sheppard who was living with the Buttons may have moved in after her death and was very likely the father of the baby.
Follow-up article dated January 24, 1898.
The Grand Jury found enough evidence to charge J. F. Button and Sheppard with murder.
February 19, 1898, Opelousas, Louisiana.
Convicted:
March 12, 1898, St. Francisville, Louisiana.
John F. Button and W. C. Sheppard are sentenced to life in prison:
March 19, 1898, St. Landry.
The appeal failed:
May 17, 1898, New Orleans, Louisiana.
From the register of the Louisiana State Penitentiary:
It states that John F. Button was born in Kentucky, and I've seen that elsewhere. That's where his father was from, but as his older and younger siblings were all born in Mississippi, I believe that is where he must have been born. He did list Mississippi as his birthplace in some records.
Here are closer views:
He was sentenced March 12, 1898, and arrived at the penitentiary July 30, 1898. He died May 20, 1899, in prison.
Death recorded at the Louisiana State Penitentiary:
Closer views:
John F. Button died in prison on May 20, 1899, at the age of 54. The above record shows 53, but I show it would have been five days past his 54th birthday. Had he lived, he would have been eligible for early release for good behavior July 13, 1913, after serving 15 years.
The Rest of the Button Family
John Feland Button's children were scattered in the 1900 census. Frank was a lodger with Henry T. Brooks in Pointe Coupee Parish, Louisiana. Bessie was married to her first husband, Claiborne Kimble, living in St. Landry Parish. Six-year-old Nellie lived with her. 20-year-old Clara, my great-grandmother, lived alone in Alexandria, Rapides Parish, Louisiana, and was a schoolteacher. Feland Button was 18 and living in the home of Theogene Smith in St. Landry Parish, Louisiana. Byron had died in 1896. I've been unable to find George Allen anywhere at any time. Katie lived with her Aunt Katie Huff in Wilkinson Co., Mississippi. I've been unable to find Mamie anywhere at any time. As stated before, Nellie lived with sister Bessie. I can't find four-year-old Claude Howard in 1900, but he shows up in 1910 in brother Feland's house in Natchez, Adams Co., Mississippi.
Frank married Emmeline Victoria Foster 23 May 1905, in St. Landry Parish, Louisiana. Bessie's second husband was Samuel Foster Jr., who was Victoria's brother. Clara married my great-grandfather, Kavanaugh Warner, in 1904. I wonder if he ever knew her secret. If anyone in my family ever knew it, they certainly didn't talk about it. Feland married Eva Estelle Hammett in 1906. Byron died young, and George may have, too, as I can't find him anywhere. Katie married James Franklin Hughes about 1913 and lived in St. Louis, Missouri. I have no idea what happened to Mamie. Nellie married first Ernest Justice and then William E. Case. Howard married Daisy Mae Pollard and then Leola Anthony.
The living Button siblings as of the early 1960's: Nellie, Clara, Howard, and Feland
I welcome any and all comments, additions, or corrections. I'd love to correspond with Button cousins. Thank you!